If you want to choose an SEO agency in Vancouver, the monthly price and a screenshot of a keyword at number one are the easiest things to compare, and neither tells you what your business will have in hand after month six.
The questions that separate one agency from another are about ownership, reporting and AI answers. Here is the order I would ask them in.
Rule out the guarantee first
Nobody can guarantee first-page rankings. An agency that writes "guaranteed page one" into a proposal is promising something it does not control, or it has picked a keyword so obscure that the promise costs nothing. Cross it off the list.
Honest timelines sound duller. On NG's own SEO page, the first ranking moves typically appear in 6 to 10 weeks and meaningful organic traffic in 3 to 6 months. So when an agency promises results in the first month for a competitive Vancouver search, ask what will be different by then, and ask to see it in writing.
Ask who owns the accounts
This question costs owners the most when it goes wrong, and it is easy to skip in a pitch. Put four questions to the agency and get the answers in writing:
- Who owns the Google Business Profile, and are you the listed owner or only a manager?
- Who owns the Google Analytics and Search Console accounts?
- Who owns the content written for your site, and does it stay on your site if you leave?
- Whose name is on the domain and the hosting?
The right answer to all four is you. The accounts are created under your email and the agency is added as a user. Google gives Business Profile owners full control, including adding and removing users, while managers have less. If the agency set up your Business Profile under its own login, your reviews and your map listing sit behind someone else's password. Analytics works the same way: years of search data are an asset only if they survive the end of the contract.
An agency worth hiring answers this in one line. A long answer full of exceptions is also an answer.
Read a sample report before you sign
Ask for a real monthly report with the client's name blacked out. A report that lists keywords and arrows pointing up is the weak version. A useful one says what was done that month, which pages came up on Google, how many people clicked through from search, and how many calls, forms and direction requests followed.
The pairing matters. Take a scaffolding company in Metro Vancouver that NG works with. Its average Google position for "scaffolding company" went from 3 to 1.3 (Aug 29 to Sep 28, 2026, against Jul 28 to Aug 28; Google Search Console). That is the screenshot number. Next to it sat 276 calls, direction requests and website visits from its Maps listing, up from 153 (September against August 2026; Google Business Profile). The second figure is the one an owner can plan a month around. The full numbers are on the scaffolding SEO case page.
Also ask for your own login to Search Console. It is free, and the figures in the report should match what you see when you open it yourself.
Ask whether they check AI answers too
Buyers now ask ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Claude for recommendations, and a business that ranks well on Google can still be missing from those answers. So ask the agency directly: do you check what these assistants say about my business, how often, and which sites do they cite?
A good agency has a routine for this and shows you the results. NG checks every month what the four assistants say about a client's business and which sites they cite. For an industrial cleaning client in BC, 76% of AI answers to buyer questions cite the site, up from 47% (Sep 24, 2026, against Jul 7; AI answer check, 3 assistants, 15 questions). Nobody gets a number like that without someone running the check and writing it down.
If the idea is new to you, start with how AI recommends local businesses, then read what AI is already telling customers about your business.
Compare what each quote includes
Price is the easy part, so check it last. NG's SEO and AEO plans run $800 a month for Starter, $1,200 for Growth and $1,800 for Pro, in Canadian dollars, month to month with no long lock-in contract. When you choose between quotes, go line by line: how many pages get written or fixed, whether Business Profile work is included, what the reporting looks like, and whether AI answer checks are part of the package. A lower monthly figure that leaves out two of those items buys less.
Ask about the end of the contract too. What happens to the content and the accounts if you stop paying in month five? That question brings you straight back to ownership.
Check the local part
For a Vancouver business, Google builds local results in Search and Maps mainly from relevance, distance and prominence, according to Google's own help pages. That makes your Business Profile as important as your website. Ask which Vancouver areas the agency would target for you and why, and whether it will tell you when a keyword you want is not worth chasing. An agency that never says no to a keyword is billing for activity.
Questions to bring to the call
- Which keyword would you advise me not to target, and why?
- Who owns the Business Profile, the analytics and the content? Will you put it in writing?
- Can I see a real monthly report?
- How do you check AI answers, and how often?
- What happens in month one, and what will I see at week 10?
- How do I leave, and what do I keep?
Take that list to two or three agencies and compare the answers side by side. Choose the one that answers plainly, shows its numbers and hands you the keys on day one. If you want NG's answers, read the SEO and AEO service page and send the same list through our quote form.